Wage rise stimulus arguments don’t add up, says Ai Group in submission


The peak national employer organisation representing business has rejected arguments that an increase in the minimum wage would have a similar positive effect on the economy as government stimulus payments.

"This argument has substantial flaws and should not be accepted by the Expert Panel of the Fair Work Commission,” said Innes Willox, Group Chief Executive of the Ai Group.

Mr Willox made these comments in his organisation’s second submission to this year’s Annual Wage Review, in which he also argued for a delay in the operative date for any potential pay increase for employers in distressed sectors

"Unlike stimulus payments, rises in minimum wages are paid by businesses and other employers and therefore involve a diversion of money from employers to those households which receive higher wages because of the minimum wage decision,” continued Mr Willox.

"Because there is no additional money injected into the economy from an increase in minimum wages, there is no comparability between stimulus payments made by governments and rises in minimum wages. One is stimulus; the other is a transfer within the economy. They are chalk and cheese.

"We also propose a delayed operative date of 1 September 2021 for any wage increase in Group 2 awards. Last year, the minimum wage increase for these awards was delayed by four months. This year, we propose a delay of two months. This would facilitate a smooth transition to a 1 July operative date for any minimum wage increase next year, if there are no ongoing 'exceptional circumstances'.”

Mr Willox proposed an operative date of 1 January 2022 for any wage increase in Group 3 awards. He said the industries covered by these awards continued to be adversely affected by the pandemic, and the 1 February 2021 delayed operative date for these awards in last year's ‘Decision’ would otherwise result in employers being required to pay two wage increases in close succession.

"Contrary to the false assertions of the ACTU, Ai Group has not yet proposed a quantum for any minimum wage increase. Our view is that the impact of the discontinuation of the JobKeeper scheme from 28 March 2021, including the extent of job losses and business closures, is not yet clear. For this reason, Ai Group will advise the Expert Panel of our position on any minimum wage increase in the round of submissions due on 14 May 2021. This will enable Ai Group to assess the latest economic data before settling on a proposed quantum for any minimum wage increase.

"The 3.5 per cent minimum wage increase proposed by the ACTU is obviously unsustainable. Such a minimum wage increase is incompatible with the current economic vulnerabilities and would put jobs at risk and worsen unemployment and underemployment," Mr Willox said.

Related news & editorials

  1. 27.10.2021
    by      In
    ‘Buy Australian Now’, the latest campaign from Australian Made is urging all Aussies to support local jobs and economic recovery by backing our local makers and growers as the country begins to open up and prepare for the festive season.
    According to Australian Made Chief Executive, Ben Lazzaro,... Read More
  2. 26.10.2021
    by      In
    Work, health and safety are fundamental to our lives and are, more than ever, a central focus for organisations.
    The Hunter region in NSW is well-known for leading the way in industry; this in turn has led to the region becoming champions of WHS.
    The Hunter Safety Awards were born out of desire to... Read More
  3. 19.10.2021
    by      In
    There is no doubt that the recent AUKUS agreement between Australia, USA and the UK was a surprise to just about everyone on the planet!
    Taking a closer look into the government’s decision to commit to the AUKUS alliance, much of what has been reported by mainstream media has been inaccurate or... Read More
  4. 18.10.2021
    by      In
    Australian Resources and Energy Group AMMA welcomes today’s intervention of the Australian Government seeking to put an end to three months of damaging strikes at Fremantle Port.
    It has been reported the Australian Government has stepped in, utilising its powers under the Fair Work Act to seek an... Read More